A review and commentary on topical matters concerning the science, economics, and governance associated with climate change developments.
1 February 2020
Joe Bastardi places the tragic bush fires in Australia inperspective.
Though woke folk will never accept hard data,Michael Shellenbergerdisposes of the myth that global fires are increasing. They are more serious than they should be in Australia only because those same woke folk prevent measures to address the risks.
Roy Spencerhas one of the most comprehensive evaluations of bush fires with this summary:
Global wildfire activity has decreased in recent decades.
Like California, Australia is prone to bushfires every year during the dry season. Ample fuel and dry weather exist for devastating fires each year, even without excessive heat or drought.
Australian average temperatures in 2019 were well above what global warming theory can explain, illustrating the importance of natural year-to-year variability.
Australia precipitation was at a record low in 2019, but climate models predict no long-term trend in Australia precipitation.
While reductions in prescribed burning have probably contributed to the irregular increase in large bush fires, a five-fold increase in population in the last 100 years has greatly increased potential ignition sources, both accidental and purposeful.
Pointing to the elimination of fire stick land management practiced by the aborigines “Giordini Bruno” points to political reasons, “Regretfully, extraordinarily little is now done to prevent bush fires in Australia. While there has been negligible precautionary burning, and reducing cleaning of public areas, citizens have also been prevented from cleaning up their own land, and the nearby reserves, by impossible rules.”Fuel load and wind conditions are the major factors in fire frequencies and intensities with heat playing a minor role. As recognised even by an alarmist like Bjorn Lömborg,“from 1997 to 2018 the burnt area declined by one-third. Australia’s current fire season has seen less area burned than in previous years”.
In November, fire expertDavid Packhamexplained thatwe have allowed fuel on the ground to increase by tenfold, which increases fire intensity one hundred fold. Without systematic burning, fuel on the ground has increased to 70 megawatts per metre and, “The maximum we can extinguish — with helicopters, bulldozers, tankers, is just 3 megawatts per metre”.Dissenting views, that have been swiftlyrebutted, claim burning is not effective.
Claims about Australia heating up more than the rest of the world are, at least in part, illusory – a result of the BoM “homogenising” earlier climate records. Only the satellite data is truly reliable and, asJo Novaillustrates, the current year is not the hottest on record.
Scientific fraud on greenhouse
At the Davos world economic forum,Donald Trumpsaid, “To embrace the possibilities of tomorrow we must reject the perennial prophets of doom and their predictions of the Apocalypse. They are the heirs of yesterday's foolish fortune tellers, and they want to see us do badly but we won't let that happen. They predicted an overpopulation crisis in the 1960s, mass starvation in the 70s, and an end of oil in the 1990s. These alarmists always demand the same thing: absolute power to dominate, transform and control every aspect of our lives.”
Walter Russell Meadexcoriated the meeting saying, “There is something inescapably ridiculous about a gathering this self-important; certainly Marie Antoinette and her friends dressing up as shepherdesses to celebrate the simple life has nothing on the more than 100 billionaires descending, often by private jet, on an exclusive Swiss ski resort for four days of ostentatious hand-wringing about the problems of the poor and the dangers of climate change.”
Peter Ridd, fired for collegial disloyalty at James Cook University (JCU), is seeing his views about scientific fraud/sloppiness in the climate change theatre, especially covering the Great Barrier Reef, being validated. A major study seeking to replicate work showing disastrous outcomes for oceanic life from increased CO2 has been debunked. OneJCU PhD recipientwas, two years ago, found guilty of scientific fraud. JCU says it had now set up aninvestigatory panel. And, as the Head of the Great Barrier Reef Authority informed Australia’s Parliament, “The reef is a vast estate and many areas remain vibrant and ecologically robust”.
The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals expressed sympathy with the young plaintiffs who sued the government, saying that a “failure to change existing policy may hasten an environmental apocalypse.” But ina 2-to-1 rulingthis was rejected.
Climate myths’ effects on economics, trade and finance
During the last 30 years themortality riskfrom climate-related disasters plunged more than six-fold and the economic loss rates went down five-fold.
Responding to pressure from agitators,Black Rock,the world’s largest asset manager, with about $7 trillion under managementis to divest shares in thermal coal firmsChief Executive Laurence Fink said, “The evidence on climate risk is compelling investors to reassess core assumptions about modern finance.” CBUSis among the US superannuation funds with similar policies. “BlackRockhas been a laggard when it comes to climate change,” said John Hewson, a renewables investor and chairman of the Business Council for Sustainable Development Australia.
Whatever the rationale foremissions, tradingin them is booming at $214 billion last year, up 34 per cent on the previous year. That is an income stream worth protecting by investing in funding media to publish favourable commentary.
Chris Hohn, the owner of The UK’s TCI Fund Management, is revealed as a major bankroller of the Extinction Rebellion. TCI is one of the largest global fund managers. Its success, which netted Hohn £800million, is due to its bets against companies that have been embroiled in environmental scandals.
Morgan Stanleyanalysts said the world needs to spend $73 trillion by 2050 to meet the Paris Agreement emission targets (a bit less than world GDP) on five areas of technology.
EU President,Ursula Von Der Leyen, threatened to impose tariff duties on nations, including US and China, that did not reduce emissions in line with EU standards. The UK seems toacquiesce in this, announcing its intent to implement a £16 per tonne carbon tax on incremental emissions.
For its partthe USsignalled that this would invite retaliation. Indeed, President Trump took no backward steps inconfronting the rich eliteswith their climate pessimism andberated European governments for their high energy prices, contrasting them with the average $2,500 reduction in electric bills of American households.
Donald Trumpalso ridiculed EU climate alarmism proclaiming, “To embrace the possibilities of tomorrow we must reject the perennial prophets of doom and their predictions of the Apocalypse. They are the heirs of yesterday's foolish fortune tellers, and they want to see us do badly but we won't let that happen. They predicted an overpopulation crisis in the 1960s, mass starvation in the 70s, and an end of oil in the 1990s. These alarmists always demand the same thing: absolute power to dominate, transform and control every aspect of our lives.”
Miranda Devinepoints out that in pressuring Boeing to supply planes with low emissions the 737 was made vulnerable to accidents and deaths.
Qatar has signed asolarpurchasing agreement at 1.57 US cents per kWh for about a quarter of its needs. This is lower than thetypical US and Australian wholesale price(2 cents and 7.5 cents respectively) though it is for power delivered whenever available. Some say it means solar is competitive, while seeking more subsidies!US subsidiesare being phased out.
Climate change is reportedly causingbirdsto fly in the wrong direction. Not soPrince Charleswho flew 16,000 miles at UK taxpayer expense to meet with Greta Thunberg, the funding of whom including her expensive security is being investigated byRebel Media.
Thriving polar bear communitieshave deprived the alarmists of one poster animal but now they have turned scare-mongering topenguins. Talking of polar bears, one claim is thateach return flight to Svalbardin Norway melts 3 square metres of ice. Luckily, the Arctic and Greenland ice is about14 million square metres, which may reduce the need for therapy “to tackle feelings of anger, guilt and grief” offered to those students and staff at the University of Derby, who are anxious aboutclimate change. Surely one such anxiety is that80 per cent of wine-producing areas are said to be threatened by climate change. Fortunately, as with all temperate crops, if the climate warms, they are relocated a few hundred kilometres.
In an “Every cloud has a silver lining” statement, Canadian politicianLuc Ferrandeztweeted,“Wuhan. No automobile traffic. No air flights. The only city on the planet that will meet its GHG reduction targets. The way to this necessary degrowth will happen when all the debates have been in vain.”