Wednesday, 3 April 2013

Extreme Exaggeration of the Climate Commission.

Climate Commission: 

extreme exaggeration and high risk of being wrong

by Anthony Cox

The Climate Commission [CC] has form for hyperbole, cherry-picking and just plain lying. It’s at it again in its latest report dealing with ‘extreme weather’.

It’s author and leading spokesperson Will Steffen was interviewed on the ABC [where else?] and said:
Well what we see is a pattern emerging that the south-west of Western Australia and the south-east of Australia have become drier - the south-west since about the mid 1970s; the south-east since about the mid 1990s. And there’s a similarity in pattern.

Well, let’s look at the Bureau of Meteorology’s own data. The South-western region’s rainfall history is shown here:

In fact rainfall has been declining since 1900 and has actually been flat since 1970.

What about the South-eastern region:

Rainfall is slightly increasing!

Steffen is well credentialed academically but has a history of being loose with the facts. And he persists in doing it!

His other partners at the CC are equally alarming in their views about climate and science; David Karoly has great form for arrogance, exaggeration, being wrong and so on but is generally regarded as the brains of the CC.

Flannery is beyond the pale and has cost Australia $billions.

Despite this the ABC leads its coverage about the CC’s latest ‘extreme weather’ report with:
The nation's top climate scientists and science bodies have for the first time endorsed a major report that says Australia's climate has shifted permanently in some cases.

What hubris; “Australia’s top climate scientists”; and they can’t even get their own facts right!

The CC claims:
Heat: Extreme heat is increasing across Australia. There will still be record cold events, but hot records are now happening three times more often than cold records.

How can we now accept that when the CC’s last report about the “Angry Summer” contained so many errors and misrepresentations? For instance Newcastle is listed as having a record temperature of 42.5C. This can be checked at the BOM site. It happened on Friday the 18/1/13. However on the same page the mean maximum for January is shown as being 26.9C. Compare that with the history of monthly mean maximum temperatures at Newcastle. The highest January maximum was in 1882 and the hottest period was before 1890.

Australia has had many floods, droughts, heatwaves, worse than what we are seeing today. The CC’s fear-mongering is ideologically based and part of the AGW scam.

After the 14 September, closing the CC should be the first step towards reinstating a rational basis to science in Australia.


  1. I would like to tell you of my latest book, “Human Caused Global Warming”.
    'The Biggest Deception in History’.
    Available on ‘’.

  2. What about this rainfall plot for all of Australia from the BOM?

  3. Now talking about heat in Perth. Have the heatwaves been increasing in Perth. Not from Jo Nova's posting on her blog. See here:

  4. It's appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy.
    I have read this post and if I could I want to suggest you some interesting things or tips.

    Perhaps you can write next articles referring to this article.
    I want to read even more things about it!

  5. Hola me ha agradado mucho esta nota, espero haber tomadobuena anotacion,
    me encanta Tailandia y espero volver proximamente me quedo chequeando
    otras mas, me sumo a esperar las novedades, muchas gracias

    1. Translated from Spanish - by Google:

      Hello, I have been very pleased with this note, I hope I have taken a good note,
      I love Thailand and I hope to come back soon I am checking
      other more, I join in waiting for the news, thank you very much

  6. What's up it's me, I am also visiting this site regularly, this web page is actually
    pleasant and the visitors are truly sharing good thoughts.


All serious comments published after moderation.
Comments should be polite, and respect all views.
No bad language. Spam never makes it!